Publication Ethis
Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
Attanwir: Jurnal Keislaman dan Pendidikan, published by Institut Attanwir Bojonegoro, Indonesia, is committed to maintaining integrity, transparency, and accountability throughout the publication process. This statement sets out the responsibilities of authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, together with procedures for addressing ethical concerns before and after publication.
1. Responsibilities of the Publisher
Institut Attanwir Bojonegoro supports the editorial team in maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record. Publication decisions must be independent of advertising, publication fees, sponsorship, and other commercial or institutional interests.
The publisher supports the investigation of ethical concerns and the publication of corrections, retractions, or other notices when necessary.
2. Editorial Responsibilities and Independence
Editors evaluate manuscripts according to their scholarly merit, originality, methodological soundness, relevance to the journal’s scope, and compliance with publication ethics. Decisions must not be influenced by an author’s gender, ethnicity, nationality, religious beliefs, political views, or institutional affiliation.
Editors are responsible for selecting suitable reviewers, considering their assessments, and making publication decisions. Acceptance must not be guaranteed in exchange for payment or other benefits.
Editors must maintain manuscript confidentiality and must not use unpublished information for personal research without the authors’ written permission.
Submissions from editors, editorial board members, or individuals with close professional or personal relationships with an editor must be handled by another editor who has no relevant conflict of interest. The submitting individual must not participate in reviewing or deciding on their own manuscript.
3. Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers assist editors in assessing manuscripts and provide constructive feedback to authors. Reviews must be objective, respectful, supported by clear reasoning, and completed within the agreed period.
Reviewers who lack the necessary expertise or cannot complete a review on time must promptly inform the editor.
Manuscripts and review materials are confidential. Reviewers must not share them with others or use unpublished information for personal advantage. Reviewers must obtain editorial permission before involving another person in a review.
Reviewers should alert the editor to suspected plagiarism, substantial overlap, unsupported claims, or other ethical concerns. They must not request citations solely to increase their own citation counts or those of associated individuals or publications.
4. Authorship Criteria
Authorship is reserved for individuals who meet all of the following criteria:
-
Make a substantial contribution to the conception or design of the study, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of its data or sources.
-
Draft the manuscript or critically revise it for significant intellectual content.
-
Approve the final version submitted for publication.
-
Agree to be accountable for their contribution and to cooperate in resolving questions about the accuracy or integrity of the work.
All individuals who meet these criteria must be included as authors. Individuals who provide assistance without meeting all authorship criteria should be acknowledged, with their permission. Funding acquisition, administrative supervision, language editing, or technical assistance alone does not qualify an individual for authorship.
The corresponding author must ensure that the author list is accurate, that all authors approve the manuscript and its submission, and that communication from the journal is shared with co-authors.
Guest, gift, honorary, and ghost authorship are unacceptable. Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot approve publication or accept responsibility for the work.
Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors after submission must include an explanation and written agreement from all affected authors, including any person being added or removed. The editor may suspend processing while an authorship dispute remains unresolved. Disputes that cannot be resolved by the authors may be referred to their institutions.
5. Reporting Standards and Research Integrity
Authors must present their research accurately and provide sufficient information about methods, evidence, and sources to allow readers to assess the work.
Fabrication, falsification, deceptive manipulation of data or images, and deliberate misrepresentation of findings are unacceptable. Authors must retain relevant research records and provide supporting information when reasonably requested, subject to applicable ethical, legal, and confidentiality restrictions.
Research involving human participants must comply with applicable ethical requirements. Authors must report ethics approval or exemption where required and explain how informed consent and participant confidentiality were addressed. Identifiable personal information must not be published without appropriate consent.
6. Originality, Plagiarism, and Redundant Publication
Authors must submit original work and appropriately acknowledge all borrowed ideas, words, data, images, and other materials. Direct quotations must be clearly identified, and permission must be obtained where necessary.
Plagiarism, inappropriate reuse of an author’s previously published material, and undisclosed redundant publication are unacceptable. Manuscripts must not be submitted to another journal while under consideration by Attanwir.
Authors must disclose related manuscripts, previous dissemination, or overlapping publications so that editors can assess their relationship to the submission.
Similarity reports are used as screening aids. A similarity percentage alone does not establish whether plagiarism has occurred; editors assess the nature, extent, attribution, and context of the overlapping material.
Suspected cases are handled through the procedures described under “Allegations of Research Misconduct.”
7. Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure
Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose financial and non-financial relationships that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their work or judgment.
Authors must disclose relevant employment, consultancy, financial interests, personal relationships, institutional interests, and other competing interests. All funding sources and the funder’s role in the research and publication process must be stated. Authors with no relevant conflicts should explicitly declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
Reviewers must decline assignments when competing interests could compromise an impartial assessment, including close collaboration, direct competition, or significant personal or institutional relationships with the authors.
Editors with a relevant conflict must withdraw from handling the manuscript and assign responsibility to an independent editor.
8. Allegations of Research Misconduct
The journal considers allegations involving submitted or published work, including suspected fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, unethical research, authorship manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and manipulation of peer review.
Concerns should be submitted through the journal’s Contact page and should identify the manuscript or article, explain the concern, and provide supporting evidence where available. Anonymous reports may be considered when they contain sufficiently specific and credible information.
The journal handles allegations through the following steps:
-
Initial assessment: An editor without a relevant conflict of interest assesses the concern and available evidence.
-
Request for clarification: The authors or other relevant parties are invited to respond and provide supporting information.
-
Further examination: The editor evaluates the response and may seek independent expert advice or refer matters requiring formal investigation to the relevant institution.
-
Editorial action: Depending on the findings, the journal may take no further action, request revisions, reject a submission, publish a correction, issue an expression of concern, or retract an article.
-
Communication and documentation: The journal records the process and communicates the outcome to relevant parties, subject to confidentiality requirements.
Editorial action is based on the available evidence and the need to protect the scholarly record. Allegations are not treated as proof of misconduct. If the concern involves an editor, it is handled by another independent editor or, where necessary, the publisher.
9. Post-Publication Discussion
The journal welcomes reasoned scholarly criticism, clarification, and discussion of published articles.
Readers may submit comments through the journal’s Contact page. Submissions should identify the article, explain the issue clearly, and provide relevant evidence or references.
Editors assess comments for relevance, accuracy, scholarly value, and respectful language. Authors may be invited to respond. Where appropriate, a comment and response may be published as correspondence or another editorially assessed contribution.
Personal attacks, unsupported accusations, and discriminatory or defamatory content are not acceptable. Concerns about possible misconduct are handled under the journal’s research misconduct procedures.
10. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
Authors who discover a significant error in their published work must promptly notify the journal and cooperate in addressing it. Editors also consider concerns raised by readers, reviewers, and other parties.
Corrections
A correction is issued when an error affects the accuracy or interpretation of part of an article but does not invalidate its overall findings.
Correction notices identify the article, describe the error and the correction, and are linked to the original article. Substantive changes must not be made silently.
Expressions of Concern
An expression of concern may be issued when there are credible questions about an article’s integrity or reliability but the available evidence is inconclusive or an investigation remains unresolved.
The notice explains the nature of the concern without presenting unconfirmed allegations as established findings.
Retractions
An article may be retracted when its findings are unreliable because of major error, fabrication, falsification, or other serious problems; when it contains plagiarism or unjustified redundant publication; when the research is unethical; or when serious manipulation has compromised the publication process.
Retraction decisions are made by the editor in consultation with the publisher and, where appropriate, independent experts or relevant institutions. Authors are given an opportunity to respond, but their agreement is not required when sufficient grounds for retraction exist.
A retraction notice identifies the article, states the reasons and who is retracting it, and is linked to the original publication. Retracted articles normally remain accessible and are clearly marked as retracted to preserve the scholarly record. Exceptional removal may be considered when necessary to meet legal obligations or address serious privacy or safety concerns.
11. Complaints and Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision by submitting a reasoned explanation and supporting evidence through the journal’s Contact page. Disagreement alone does not establish grounds for reversing a decision.
Complaints about editorial conduct, publication procedures, or ethical issues are assessed by an editor without a relevant conflict of interest. Complaints concerning the Editor-in-Chief are referred to the publisher for independent consideration.
The journal communicates the outcome after reviewing the available information. Appeals do not guarantee acceptance or a change in the original decision.
12. Contact for Ethical Concerns
Questions, complaints, appeals, post-publication comments, and reports of suspected misconduct should be directed to the editorial office using the contact details available at:
