Peer Review Process

Attanwir: Jurnal Keislaman dan Pendidikan applies a double-blind peer review process: authors’ identities are concealed from reviewers, and reviewers’ identities are concealed from authors.

Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial assessment are evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Reviewers provide recommendations, while the final publication decision rests with the editor.

1. Manuscript Submission

Authors submit manuscripts through the journal’s Open Journal Systems (OJS):

Make a Submission

Submissions must follow the Author Guidelines and use the journal’s official template. Authors must provide complete author information in the submission metadata and prepare an anonymized manuscript for review, removing identifying information from the text and file properties.

2. Initial Editorial Assessment

The editorial team checks each submission for:

  • Relevance to the journal’s Focus and Scope.

  • Compliance with the Author Guidelines.

  • Originality and potential scholarly contribution.

  • Clarity of presentation and adequacy of the research methods or conceptual approach.

  • Compliance with research and publication ethics.

Manuscripts may be returned for technical corrections or rejected without external review when they do not meet these requirements.

Manuscripts passing the initial assessment are screened using Turnitin. Similarity reports are assessed according to the journal’s Plagiarism Policy; similarity percentages alone do not establish plagiarism.

3. Assignment of a Handling Editor

The Editor-in-Chief assigns an appropriate handling editor to oversee the review process.

Editors must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and withdraw from handling manuscripts when impartiality could be compromised.

Submissions authored by editors or editorial board members are handled by another editor without a relevant conflict of interest and undergo the same assessment and review requirements as other submissions. Authors must not participate in editorial decisions concerning their own manuscripts.

4. Selection and Invitation of Reviewers

The handling editor invites reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript’s subject matter and methodology within Islamic studies, education, or other areas covered by the journal’s scope.

Each manuscript proceeding to external review is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers. Reviewers are selected with consideration of their expertise, availability, and potential conflicts of interest.

5. Reviewer Acceptance and Confidentiality

Invited reviewers must assess whether they have the expertise and time to complete the review and disclose any relevant conflicts of interest before accepting.

Reviewers who cannot provide an impartial or timely assessment must decline the invitation or promptly notify the editor.

Manuscripts and review materials must be treated as confidential. Reviewers must not disclose them, involve another person without editorial permission, or use unpublished information for personal advantage. If a reviewer recognizes an author’s identity, the reviewer must inform the editor of any resulting conflict of interest.

6. Manuscript Evaluation

Reviewers assess the manuscript objectively and provide constructive comments supported by clear reasoning. Assessment considers:

  • Relevance to the journal’s scope.

  • Originality and scholarly contribution.

  • Clarity of the research objectives or central argument.

  • Engagement with relevant literature.

  • Appropriateness and transparency of the methods or analytical approach.

  • Adequacy of the evidence and interpretation.

  • Coherence of the discussion and conclusions.

  • Accuracy of citations and compliance with ethical requirements.

Reviewers recommend acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or rejection. They must report suspected ethical concerns confidentially to the editor.

7. Editorial Decision

The editor considers the manuscript and reviewer reports before deciding whether to:

  • Accept the manuscript.

  • Request minor revisions.

  • Request major revisions.

  • Reject the manuscript.

Reviewer recommendations inform the decision but do not determine it automatically. Where reports differ substantially or further expertise is needed, the editor may seek clarification or invite an additional reviewer.

The decision and relevant anonymized reviewer comments are communicated to the corresponding author through OJS.

8. Revision and Reassessment

Authors receiving a revision request must submit:

  • A revised manuscript addressing the editorial and reviewer comments.

  • A point-by-point response explaining the changes made.

  • A reasoned explanation for any suggestion that has not been adopted.

Authors must submit revisions within the period stated in the decision letter or request an extension from the editor.

Major revisions are normally returned to the reviewers for reassessment. Minor revisions may be assessed by the handling editor, who may consult reviewers where necessary. Further review rounds may be required.

A revision request does not guarantee acceptance. The editor makes the final decision after considering the revised manuscript and any additional assessments.

9. Acceptance and Production

Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, layout, and proofreading. Authors may be asked to check proofs for accuracy before publication.

Substantive changes introduced during production may require further editorial assessment. Published articles are freely accessible under the journal’s Open Access Policy and stated publication license.

10. Review Timelines

Review duration varies according to reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and the extent of revisions required. The editorial team monitors progress and communicates requests and decisions through OJS.

Authors may contact the editorial office to inquire about the status of their submissions.

11. Appeals and Ethical Concerns

Authors may appeal an editorial decision by providing a reasoned explanation and supporting evidence through the journal’s Contact page.

Appeals, complaints, and suspected ethical violations are handled according to the journal’s Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement, with consideration by an editor or publisher representative who has no relevant conflict of interest.

Contact Information