Post Publication Discussion

Al-Ihath: Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam recognizes the importance of post-publication discussion in promoting scholarly dialogue, critical evaluation, and the continuous development of knowledge in the fields of Islamic guidance and counseling, counseling, psychology, and related disciplines. The journal welcomes constructive comments, scholarly critiques, and evidence-based discussions concerning articles that have been published in the journal.

Readers and researchers who identify potential errors, methodological concerns, limitations, or issues related to the interpretation of findings in a published article are encouraged to submit their comments to the editorial office. All submissions must be written in a professional and respectful manner, supported by relevant evidence, and focused on the scholarly content of the publication. Personal attacks, defamatory statements, and unsupported allegations will not be considered.

The editorial team will evaluate submitted comments and determine whether they warrant further review, a response from the original author(s), or other appropriate editorial action. Where relevant, the original author(s) may be invited to respond to the comments to facilitate a balanced and constructive academic discussion. All submissions and responses are subject to editorial assessment to ensure their relevance, accuracy, fairness, and compliance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

If post-publication discussions reveal substantive errors, concerns regarding research integrity, or other issues that may affect the reliability of a published article, the journal will investigate the matter in accordance with established publication ethics principles and applicable editorial procedures. Depending on the findings, appropriate actions may include publishing a correction, an editorial statement, an expression of concern, or a retraction, where justified.

The journal is committed to ensuring that post-publication discussions contribute to the advancement of scientific knowledge while upholding academic integrity, transparency, fairness, and respect for all parties involved. Relevant comments, author responses, and editorial notices may be published as part of the scholarly record, subject to editorial approval and the journal's publication policies.